While out-of-state foodies tend to flock to our big cities when visiting New York, residents will be the first to tell you that some of our most amazing eateries can be found hiding away within our smallest towns. These charming destinations in our state almost always have their own bakery, giving you the best of both worlds with everything from sweet to savory goods. Find out why this one secluded bakery in the Empire State is worth a road trip!
Way out in Western New York in Chautauqua County, there’s a small-town bakery that’s been blowing people away for nearly thirty years.
Google Maps
Located on Main Street in Fredonia, Upper Crust Bakery is less than 10-minutes away from the shores of Lake Erie out in our westernmost corner.
Upper Crust Bakery & Soup Co./Facebook
While this area may seem secluded from the rest of New York, there are plenty of perks that come along with visiting towns like Fredonia.
Upper Crust Bakery & Soup Co./Facebook
Using natural ingredients to create flavorful and fresh homemade goods, it’s easy to find your mouth watering uncontrollably as soon as you walk through the door.
Marie D/TripAdvisor
Upper Crust has fully mastered how to bake the perfect scones, buns, turnovers, cakes and every other sweet treat that you could desire.
Upper Crust Bakery & Soup Co./Facebook
The owners appear to effortlessly come up with the most wonderful homemade recipes and baked goods, creating unique things in the past like their corn and asiago cheese muffins!
Upper Crust Bakery & Soup Co./Facebook
In the morning you’ll find hungry locals trying to start of their day with one of Upper Crust’s various Egg-rritos - filled with egg, cheese, tomatoes, red onion and other treasured breakfast ingredients.
Upper Crust Bakery & Soup Co./Facebook
And in the afternoons you’ll find people gushing over their sandwiches, made with homemade old-fashioned bread that’s deliciously thick. Bonus? They actually roast their own turkeys for their sandwiches!
Upper Crust Bakery & Soup Co./Facebook
On Thursdays you’ll get the treat of finding gourmet pizzas on their menu, something many of us anticipate devouring.
Upper Crust Bakery & Soup Co./Facebook
It’d also be no surprise if by now you’re feeling thirsty, perfectly working out that Upper Crust has espresso, smoothies and other drinks that never disappoint.
Upper Crust Bakery & Soup Co./Facebook
With homemade menu items like their soups, sandwiches and baked treats that have earned a local following, Upper Crust Bakery in Fredonia is one quaint bakery that deserves your attention.
andrew61NewYork/TripAdvisor If you’re looking for something other than a baked good that will leave you feeling more full, you won’t want to miss out on trying one of the roughly 4 different soups that you can find freshly made here everyday. All of the soup recipes have been created by the owners, with Chautauqua County residents giving their stamp of approval. To find out more about Upper Crust Bakery and to view their menus, click here.
How to get here - 27 East Main Street Fredonia, NY 14063
You can never know about too many good places to eat! Read about these 7 New York Restaurants That Are So Much More Than Just Amazing Places To Eat!
Google Maps
Upper Crust Bakery & Soup Co./Facebook
Marie D/TripAdvisor
andrew61NewYork/TripAdvisor
If you’re looking for something other than a baked good that will leave you feeling more full, you won’t want to miss out on trying one of the roughly 4 different soups that you can find freshly made here everyday. All of the soup recipes have been created by the owners, with Chautauqua County residents giving their stamp of approval. To find out more about Upper Crust Bakery and to view their menus, click here.
How to get here - 27 East Main Street Fredonia, NY 14063
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
