There’s nothing more deliciously indulgent than cheesecake. After all, there’s no chance of dry or crumbly layers when it’s all dense, cream cheesy goodness. If you think you need to go to New York for one of these beauties, you’re in for a pleasant surprise – we have an incredible award-winning cheesecake bakery right here in New Hampshire.

Pleasant Lake Cheesecake Company in New London is the result of two decades of at-home cheesecake experimentation by dentist Mary Wicenski. Now we’re all lucky enough to enjoy the fruits of those long years of tinkering!

Facebook/Pleasant Lake Cheesecake Company

If you assume cheesecakes are always flat and unadorned, this spot will change your mind quickly. Flavors like Black Forest Cheesecake with chocolate cheesecake, whipped cream, and cherries will blow your mind.

Facebook/Pleasant Lake Cheesecake Company

The Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake is absolutely perfect for all the Reese’s lovers in your life.

Facebook/Pleasant Lake Cheesecake Company

With cheesecakes ranging from Cookies and Cream to Cherry Limeade, you’re sure to find something for every palate. And if you don’t, feel free to talk to the owner and she’ll try to recreate your favorite flavor!

TripAdvisor/m485d

Don’t want to commit to an entire cheesecake? (Trust us, we understand that the problem wouldn’t be leftovers). You’re in luck! Pleasant Lake Cheesecake Company makes nearly all their flavors in 2 inch cakes that you can buy individually or by the dozen.

Pleasant Lake Cheesecake Company

Seriously, if you can resist a picture like this we aren’t sure if you’re human.

TripAdvisor/m485d

This adorable shop also make some seriously gorgeous decorated cookies, as well as classic cakes. Perfect for a special occasion!

Facebook/Pleasant Lake Cheesecake Company

You can find Pleasant Lake Cheesecake Company at Scytheville Row Shopping Center at 75 Newport Road, Unit 108 in New London, NH. They’re open Tuesday–Saturday, 10 a.m.–6 p.m. Stop by and see what tempts you from the bakery case, or order a special creation for your next event!

Facebook/Pleasant Lake Cheesecake Company

TripAdvisor/m485d

Pleasant Lake Cheesecake Company

Facebook/Pleasant Lake Cheesecake Company

For more information (and more pictures of cheesecake) visit their website.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.